GIA vs IGI gemstone reports: what they say and how to read them
A complete practical guide to understanding independent gemological laboratory reports, treatment disclosures, and online verification.
Quick answer: A GIA or IGI gemstone report is an independent document that identifies a stone, says whether it is natural or laboratory-grown, and describes its treatments. Read the identification line and the treatment line, check the report number on the laboratory's website, and make sure the stone matches the report. GIA does not grade the quality of coloured stones.

Key facts
- ✔ GIA offers two coloured stone reports: an Identification Report and an Identification & Origin Report. Only the second gives an opinion on geographic origin.
- ✔ GIA does not grade or provide quality analysis for sapphire or other coloured stones.
- ✔ A report confirms what a stone is. It does not say whether the stone suits your birth chart.
What do GIA and IGI gemstone reports tell you?
Both laboratories issue reports that identify the stone by species and variety, for example "natural corundum, sapphire". GIA describes its coloured stone reports as identifying the type of gemstone, whether it is natural or synthetic, detectable treatments, and a description of the cut, shape, weight, measurements and colour, with a photograph. IGI issues coloured stone reports in a similar style, and each report shows its own identification wording and report number.
To read more about gemstone testing standards, explore the official GIA sapphire buyer's guide.
What is on a gemstone report, line by line?
Identification (species and variety): what the stone actually is, such as natural sapphire or natural ruby.
Natural or laboratory-grown: the report states which. See our guide to natural and lab-grown gemstones.
Treatment: whether the stone has been heated, filled, oiled or otherwise enhanced. This is the line that most affects value. See our guide to heated, unheated and treated stones.
Origin: the country of origin is given only on an origin report, and as an informed gemological opinion.
Weight and measurements: confirm these match the physical stone in front of you using precision scales and calipers.
Report number: use this unique alphanumeric number to check the report directly with the laboratory's digital database. Read our blue sapphire certification guide for deeper market context.
The "Natural" Gemstone Trap: What Your Certificate Must Say
One of the most common pitfalls when buying a gemstone in Calgary is relying solely on the word "Natural". Gemological laboratories such as GIA and IGI identify stones by their physical origin: if a sapphire or ruby was mined from the ground, its species line will state "Natural Corundum"—even if that stone has undergone high-temperature heat treatment, glass fissure filling, or chemical diffusion.
The word "Natural" confirms that the stone is not lab-grown, but it does NOT confirm that the stone is untreated. That is why your certificate must explicitly disclose the treatment status. What your report must say: for an unheated stone, look for the laboratory's definitive statement such as "no indications of heating" or "unheated". If a seller presents a certificate that only says "Natural" and the treatment field is blank, vague, or omitted, you do not have proof of whether the stone was enhanced.
- ✔ A certificate stating "Natural Sapphire" can still be heavily heat-treated or fracture-filled.
- ✔ For Vedic astrology, an unheated stone must state "no indications of heating" on the GIA or IGI report.
- ✔ Never rely on verbal seller promises—always insist that the treatment disclosure is printed directly on the laboratory report.
| Feature | Basic "Local Lab" Certificate | Independent Lab Report (GIA, IGI) |
|---|---|---|
| The "Natural" Claim | Labels the stone as "Natural Sapphire" to imply purity. | Labels it "Natural Sapphire" but rigorously tests for human interference. |
| Treatment Disclosure | Often leaves the treatment or comments section blank, hiding heat or glass-filling. | Explicitly states "No indication of thermal treatment" or details exact treatments. |
| Astrological Reliability | High risk of buying a heavily treated stone with no cosmic value. | 100% transparent. You know exactly what energy you are getting. |
Does GIA grade sapphires and other coloured stones?
No. Unlike its diamond reports, GIA does not grade or provide quality analysis for sapphire or other coloured stones. Its coloured stone reports identify the stone and describe treatments and, where requested, origin. That is why the treatment line matters so much.
GIA vs IGI: which report is better?
Both are internationally recognised laboratories. We do not rank them. What matters is that the report is genuine, matches the stone, comes from a laboratory you can verify, and states the treatment in clear words. Report layouts and wording differ, so read each report rather than assuming. Ask the jeweller which laboratory issued it and whether it covers this exact stone.
How do I check a report is genuine?
Ask for the report number and look it up on the laboratory's official verification website. Confirm that the weight, measurements, variety and photograph match the stone. If anything differs, ask why before you buy.
Why does the treatment line matter for astrological gemstones?
Many Vedic traditions prefer stones that have not been heated, so astrologers often ask for an unheated stone. Wording differs by laboratory. GIA typically reports an unheated stone with phrases such as "no indications of heating". If your Jyotishi has asked for an unheated stone, look for that statement and ask the jeweller to point to it.
What if a stone has no report?
For a valuable stone, ask whether it can be sent to a laboratory before you decide, how long that takes and what it costs. A seller who refuses to discuss it is a warning sign.
Certified gemstones at VJ Jewellers Ltd. / VJ Jewellers in Calgary
At VJ Jewellers Ltd. / VJ Jewellers in Cityscape NE Calgary, ask which GIA or IGI report comes with a specific stone and we will walk you through what it says. We serve customers from Calgary NE, Airdrie, Chestermere, Cochrane and across Alberta. Call 403-899-2121, or visit us at Cityscape Landing Plaza, 4310 104 Ave NE Unit 5126.
✨ Related Guides & Certified Gemstone Collections:
Ready to Experience the VJ Jewellers Difference?
Visit our Calgary NE showroom or consult with our team on custom designs and live rate purchases.
Verify Gemstone Certificates In-Store →📍 VJ Jewellers Ltd. / VJ Jewellers — Cityscape NE Calgary
Unit 5126, 4310 104 Ave NE, Cityscape Landing Plaza, Calgary, AB T3N 1W5
Calgary’s premier destination for certified 22K gold, bridal jewellery, and GIA diamonds.🕒 Store Hours: Open Mon to Wed & Thu to Sun at 11:00 AM with Tuesday Off (Tuesday Closed)